San Pedro remains on alert following last week’s tragic triple murder, and while police moved swiftly to make an arrest, new developments are now adding another layer of complexity to the case. Authorities had announced that 22-year-old Shelby Jonathan Hernandez was formally charged with three counts of murder in connection with the deaths of Karim Nazim Espat, Oscar Modesto Mas, and Yerlin Marisol Bueso Alvarez. The killings, which occurred on Thursday, March 19, in the Mosquito Coast area, are believed to be tied to an ongoing rivalry between drug factions on the island.
Police responded quickly in the aftermath, deploying additional personnel and a major crimes team to San Pedro, aiming not only to solve the case but also to prevent any retaliation that could escalate tensions further. Several suspects were detained, and operations across the island were intensified.
That swift response has been widely acknowledged and appreciated by the community. However, a new development is now raising questions. Hernandez’s family is publicly insisting that he is innocent of the triple murder charges, claiming that surveillance footage places him at home during the time of the shooting. According to relatives, the video shows him stepping out of his room multiple times between 9:15 p.m. and 9:41 p.m., which they say coincides with the time frame of the attack.
“We got all the video footage, and all of us can say that he was at the house the moment when that happened,” his brother stated in an interview with News Five. The family further claims that this footage was shown to police, but despite that, charges were still brought against him. Hernandez is expected to be arraigned soon on the triple murder.
These claims introduce a critical element to the case, one that will now need to be carefully examined as the investigation and legal process continue. As with any serious matter, due process will be key in determining the truth.
Follow Ambergris Today on Instagram
Triple Murder Wakeup Call
Meanwhile, the Broader concern for San Pedro Remains:
This marks the first murder recorded on the island for 2026, following a relatively low figure of just one murder reported in 2025, a case involving a domestic dispute. These numbers are important. They remind us that San Pedro is not a community overwhelmed by murder, but rather one facing targeted incidents tied to specific criminal elements.
And that distinction matter; San Pedro remains one of Belize’s safest and most important tourism destinations. But incidents like this show how quickly things can shift if underlying issues are not addressed. Police have acknowledged that the rivalry connected to this case is not new. The Espat name has appeared in past investigations tied to gang-related activity, with a history of violent incidents affecting members of the family and rival groups. These cycles of violence tend to quiet down, only to resurface again, often with tragic consequences.
Residents urge the authorities to work on prevention with increased police presence, ongoing investigations, and a clear focus on stopping retaliation. The message from the community remains clear: enforcement must continue, not just in response to tragedy, but as a preventative measure.
We commend the San Pedro Police Department for their swift action and strong presence in the immediate aftermath of this incident; a triple murder is very alarming. But this moment calls for sustained effort, more patrols, proactive policing, intelligence-led operations, and long-term strategies to dismantle the criminal elements that threaten the peace of the island.
San Pedro’s strength has always been its resilience. Now, it must also be its resolve. The goal is not just to solve this case, but to ensure that our island remains safe, stable, and welcoming for everyone who calls it home and for those who come to experience its beauty.
